Besides the numerous arguments about how test scores as an evaluative measure are short-sighted and erroneous, this type of federal mandate, in my opinion, goes too far. The States themselves are supposed to be in charge of their own educational systems, and this type of declaration threatens local control of education.
How sad that a cash-strapped and already struggling education system is now being potentially coerced into an evaluative measure that the educators know is flawed and could fundamentally change education in the state.
FYI: Here are the points Duncan says States need to adhere to in order to gain the federal funds:
- “Lift restrictions on the growth of charter schools;”
- “build data systems that show individual student progress under specific teachers and principals;”
- “seek out new ways to turn around perennially struggling schools; and”
- “sign on to efforts to develop common academic standards that are tough enough to withstand international scrutiny.”
Side note: When discussing data systems no one in charge talks about student capacity, only test scores.
